Skip to content
Adeel Razzaq

Rent vs. Buy Calculator for Long Island & Queens

Compare renting and owning over the years you plan to stay.

Over 7 years

Renting wins

Total rent paid
$294,239
Net cost of owningPayments, tax, upkeep, buying costs minus equity after a 6% sale cost
$302,399
Difference
$8,160

Estimate only — not legal or tax advice.

How it works

Whether buying beats renting depends mostly on how long you stay. Buying has large upfront and exit costs, but each payment builds equity and the home may appreciate. Renting is flexible, but every dollar is spent. This calculator compares both paths over the same time horizon.

Read moreShow less

Enter your current rent and expected yearly increase, then the price of a home you would consider, your down payment, rate and property tax rate. The calculator totals your rent over the period. For owning, it adds mortgage payments, property tax, an estimate of 1% of the price per year for upkeep and about 3% for buying costs, then subtracts the equity you would have after selling with a 6% allowance for sale costs.

The appreciation rate matters a lot. Use a conservative figure; past performance in Nassau and Queens does not guarantee future gains. Try a few scenarios — a shorter stay, flat prices, a higher rate — to see where the answer flips.

The comparison does not include tax deductions, the investment return you might earn on a down payment, or rent-stabilized situations, which can change the math in Queens. It is a framework, not a verdict.

If buying looks close, a conversation helps. Adeel can show you what similar homes have sold for and what monthly costs look like in the towns you are weighing.

FAQ

Questions, answered.

It varies, but buying usually needs several years to offset purchase and sale costs. Try different stays in the calculator.

Use a conservative estimate. Appreciation is never guaranteed.

No. Mortgage interest and property tax deductions depend on your situation; ask a tax professional.

About 1% of the home price per year, a common planning rule.

Talk it through with Adeel

Numbers are a start. A broker makes them real.